Skip to content

The 7 Laws of Disruption: Why Incumbents Rarely Change the Game

Disruption in business rarely comes from the leaders of an industry. Instead, it is driven by outsiders, startups, or players from completely different verticals who see opportunities incumbents overlook. This pattern repeats across technology, retail, hospitality, finance, and more.

Here are the 7 Laws of Disruption, backed with global and Indian examples.

Law 1 – Disruption Rarely Comes From Within

Incumbents are trapped by their revenue streams, customer expectations, and legacy infrastructure. They prefer incremental improvement instead of radical shifts.

Examples:

  • Smartphones: Nokia, Motorola, and BlackBerry improved keypads, but disruption came from Apple (outsider to phones) and Google (outsider via Android).
  • Search Engines: Yahoo and AOL dominated, but Google (then a Stanford research project) redefined search.
  • Restaurants: Domino’s or McDonald’s didn’t build food delivery apps; Zomato and Swiggy did.
  • Retail: Walmart, Sears, or Big Bazaar didn’t lead e-commerce; Amazon, Flipkart, and Alibaba did.
  • Education: Pearson, Oxford, or universities didn’t pioneer digital edtech; Byju’s, Unacademy, Coursera, and Khan Academy did.

Law 2 – Outsiders See What Insiders Can’t

Fresh eyes are not burdened by “how things have always been done.” Outsiders spot unmet needs incumbents ignore.

Examples:

  • Hospitality: Airbnb came from strangers renting out air mattresses, not Marriott or Hilton.
  • Budget Hotels: OYO Rooms started by a 20-year-old outsider, not Indian hotel chains like Taj or Oberoi.
  • Travel: MakeMyTrip started by Deep Kalra, not by legacy travel agencies like Thomas Cook or Cox & Kings.
  • Urban Services: UrbanClap (now Urban Company) was built by young founders, not existing service contractors.
  • Healthcare: Practo was launched by entrepreneurs, not by Apollo or Fortis hospitals.

Law 3 – New Business Models Beat Old Products

Disruption often comes not from “better versions” of existing products, but from redefining the business model.

Examples:

  • Media: Netflix introduced subscriptions + streaming, killing Blockbuster’s rentals.
  • Music: Spotify built a freemium streaming model, disrupting record labels.
  • Transport: Uber and Ola created app-based ride-hailing, not new cars.
  • Logistics: Delhivery and Ecom Express digitized parcel delivery, while DTDC and BlueDart stayed traditional.
  • Education: Udemy and Coursera built marketplaces for online learning, instead of traditional degree models.

Law 4 – Incumbents From Other Verticals Can Disrupt

Sometimes incumbents disrupt industries they were never part of, leveraging resources, scale, and fresh thinking.

Examples:

  • Telecom: Reliance Jio (energy & retail giant) disrupted Airtel and Vodafone.
  • Cloud Computing: Amazon (e-commerce) created AWS, not IBM, Oracle, or Dell.
  • Mobile Phones: Apple (computers/music) disrupted Nokia and BlackBerry with the iPhone.
  • Payments: Google (search) and Apple (devices) entered fintech with GPay and Apple Pay, not banks like SBI or ICICI.
  • EVs: BYD (battery maker) disrupted global auto giants with electric cars.

Law 5 – Technology Democratizes, Incumbents Monetize

Startups often create breakthrough tech. Incumbents then scale, regulate, and integrate it into the mainstream.

Examples:

  • AI: OpenAI built GPT; Microsoft scaled it with Copilot across Office and Azure.
  • Short Video: TikTok popularized it; Meta copied with Reels, YouTube with Shorts.
  • Cryptocurrency & Blockchain: Bitcoin started by Satoshi Nakamoto; PayPal, Stripe, and banks later integrated crypto/payments.
  • Food Delivery: Swiggy and Zomato built it; McDonald’s and Domino’s later integrated delivery apps.

Law 6 – Aggregators Win Where Markets Are Fragmented

Whenever industries are unorganized and fragmented, outsiders create digital aggregators to organize supply and demand.

Examples:

  • Hotels: OYO aggregated budget hotels.
  • Cabs: Uber and Ola aggregated drivers.
  • Food: Zomato and Swiggy aggregated restaurants.
  • Local Services: UrbanClap aggregated electricians, cleaners, and plumbers.
  • Healthcare: Practo aggregated doctors and clinics.
  • Freelancing: Upwork and Fiverr aggregated freelancers.

Law 7 – The Disruptor Becomes the Next Incumbent

Every disruptor eventually becomes the status quo, vulnerable to the next wave of innovation.

Examples:

  • Search: Google disrupted Yahoo, but now risks disruption from AI-first search tools.
  • E-Commerce: Amazon disrupted retail, but faces competition from social commerce (TikTok Shop, Meesho).
  • Automobiles: Tesla disrupted autos, but now faces challenges from BYD, VW, and Toyota in EVs.
  • Social Media: Facebook disrupted Orkut, but now faces TikTok.
  • Education: Byju’s disrupted publishing, but itself is challenged by Unacademy, PhysicsWallah, and AI tutors.

⚖️ The Disruption Cycle

Outsiders Spark 💡 → Niche Adoption 🌱 → Incumbents Scale 📈 → Consolidation 🏢 → Next Outsiders Spark Again 🔁

Bottom Line:
Disruption is almost never initiated by the dominant incumbents of a vertical. It comes from outsiders with fresh perspectives, or from incumbents of other industries who enter with no baggage. The cycle then repeats, as today’s disruptors become tomorrow’s incumbents.

Latest

Vivek Tiwari – Architect of Financial Inclusion, Champion of the Underserved

Vivek Tiwari – Architect of Financial Inclusion, Champion of the Underserved

Alumnus – JNV Gauri Ganj (Amethi-Sultanpur) | 1987–1994 Batch (PCB) Founder & Managing Director – Satya Micro Capital Ltd | Visionary in Microfinance & Social Entrepreneurship Early Foundations – A Navodaya Spark When Vivek Tiwari stepped into the gates of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya, Gauri Ganj (Amethi-Sultanpur) in 1987, he entered an institution that was

Dr. Chinnababu Sunkavalli – Pioneer of Robotic Oncology and Global Advocate for Cancer Care

Dr. Chinnababu Sunkavalli – Pioneer of Robotic Oncology and Global Advocate for Cancer Care

Alumnus – JNV Shivamogga, Karnataka (1986–1993 Batch) Director, Surgical Oncology and Robotic Surgery – Yashoda Hospitals, Hyderabad; Founder & CEO – Grace Cancer Foundation Early Life and Navodaya Foundation Dr. Chinnababu Sunkavalli’s journey began in the quiet setting of Shivamogga, Karnataka, where he became part of the very first batch of